Sunday, July 22, 2012

POKA YOKE - Applying Mistake Proofing to Software


For years, automobile companies have utilized "Mistake Proofing" as a technique for ensuring high quality, high speed manufacturing -- especially in cases of mass scale production. This is also known as Poka-Yoke (in Japanese) and was adopted and formalized as part of the Toyota Production System. This blog attempts to raise awareness (with examples) for the need of Poka Yoke in Software Design and within the Software Development process.

What is Poka Yoke?


The essential idea of Poka Yoke is to Mistake Proof the manufacturing process so that workers in a plant cannot make mistakes easily, or if a mistake is made, it is detected and corrected quickly. 

There are two types of Poka Yokes:

Control Poka Yoke: A Control Poka Yoke is one where the process is designed in such a manner that one cannot make a mistake.

For instance, a car manufacturer might want to put special heat resistant bolts in the engine assembly. For this, the bolts can be made to be of a certain dimension such that it only fits the engine assembly, and nowhere else. Therefore, one cannot use the special bolts in any place except the engine assembly, and one can also not inadvertently put the wrong (non-heat resistant) bolt in the engine assembly

This is a form of control poka yoke, where one cannot go wrong, or make a mistake.

Another interesting example of a control poka yoke are the Gas connections in an Emergency Room at the hospital. To ensure that someone doesn’t connect the wrong gas pipes to the wrong outlets, the Pin configuration of the connections are designed to be unique for each Gas outlet (a standard called the Pin Index Safety System).

Mistake Proofing via different Pin Configurations
Warning Poka Yoke: A warning Poka Yoke is one where the moment someone makes a mistake, the person is quickly notified of the mistake, so that corrective action can be taken.

An example of a Warning Poka yoke is the Car Seatbelt Warning indicator. If one forgets to put on the Seat Belt, then it will beep to warn you of the fact that you forgot to put it on.

Check out the following catalog of Poka Yoke examples from John Grout’s website:

The Need For Poka Yoke in Software

There are very compelling reasons to use Poka Yokes in Software Design for the benefit of end users, and also in Software Development Teams for creating high quality software in shorter time-frames.  

In Software Design

Beautiful software is designed in a manner that it is intuitive and transparent to the user. It meets the need in a fluid manner, assisting the user to do just what he/she would like to do with it, without making the user jump through hoops and millions of clicks. It should be like an extension of the body, which one uses sub-consciously. 

To create such Beautiful software, it is imperative that it is designed with the user behavior, psychology and needs at the core of all thought. When the user naturally moves through the software with ease, we can perceive it as a form of Control Poke Yoke, that ensures that one doesn’t make costly mistakes while using the software.   For instance, a simple control Poka Yoke feature is the “Auto Save” feature of Gmail, which ensures that a user’s email is auto-saved every few minutes, so that loss of the internet connection doesn’t make the user lose his/her data. This is an indication of detailed thought gone into understanding the users behavior and needs.

We will look at few more examples of Poka Yoke in software design in the following sections.

In Software Development Teams

The need for Poka Yoke in Software Development teams is higher than ever before. It is quite well established in the industry that the cost of fixing a defect amplifies 10 to 100 times depending on how far the defect has gone unnoticed in the development process. Couple that with the need for integrating with tens of systems nowadays, and the problem gets compounded manifold.  Delegating software development to large number of mediocre or inexperienced developers, isn’t helping the cause.  Introducing a poka yoke, that catches defects early, makes Discovery and Diagnosis of a defect ridiculously easy. Of course, to design a Poka Yoke, one needs to be aware of possible mistakes that could potentially occur -- and that comes from feedback, retrospectives and burnt fingers across a project or multiple projects.

The point of a Poka Yoke is: Making mistakes is OK, just don’t make the same mistake again and again.

Quite frequently on large projects, or long running projects, or on projects with multiple and remote  teams -- communication becomes a severe issue. In such projects it is very difficult to keep all folks “on the same page”. One finds people sending emails in BOLD, or writing and maintaining huge Wiki pages with FAQ and ToDos on how to perform a certain task. Unfortunately, no one has the time to read or maintain these documents, and errors slip through the cracks.

For instance, on one of my Travel projects, to perform test bookings, we had to use live GDS inventory. So we were given instructions on attributes of a test booking. These went something like: Make bookings at least 6 months in advance, and don’t book during Christmas, or New Year season, don’t book ABC and XYZ airlines, cancel the ticket within 20 minutes of doing the bookings, etc.

Now, even though people followed these rules, quite a few folks would forget to follow at least one or more of these rules. As a result, one time a large airline sent our Travel booking agency a huge bill for messing up with their ticket prices because apparently some test program did a huge number of bookings & cancellations for their flights -- and caused their ticket prices to go up, resulting in shooing away of “real” customers. Now, this can be easily avoided by putting a Poka yoke that would reject any bookings sent via our service that didn’t meet the criteria. And -- that’s really quite easy in software!

In today’s world, the array of tools and techniques available to us are immense. We must use these tools smartly, so that we concentrate on more pressing issues, and let poka yokes, automation scripts and smart checks catch common, and well understood project issues.

Instead of sending multiple BOLD font emails, create a Poka Yoke -- to ensure things don’t break again, and mistakes and errors don’t slip through.

Qualities of a Good Poka Yoke

A good Poka Yoke must meet the following qualities:

  • Early: A good poka yoke must be early in the process, so that it can provide quick feedback -- and help in detecting mistakes the moment they occur.
  • Precise: It should be precise, so that it is easy to diagnose and identify what mistake occurred.
  • Simple: The poka yoke should be simple -- to develop and maintain. This is quite important since one doesn’t want to spend time and effort in maintaining poka yokes, and complex poka yokes will have a fairly high chance of becoming erroneous. Having a buggy poka yoke is worse than having no poka yoke at all.
  • Light: The poka yoke needs to be unobtrusive and transparent. If a poka yoke itself becomes an overhead to the process, then it will drive the developers/users crazy, and they will find ingenious ways to avoid it all together. For instance, think about how a developer will feel if he/she has to run a 70 minute pre-commit script before each and every check-in!

Examples of Poka Yoke in Software Design (for End Users)

  1. Gmail Attachment Check: If one uses the words "I have attached", but does not attach any document to the email, Gmail will give a warning saying you used the words I have attached, but didn't really attach any document. Are you sure this isn't a mistake?
  2. Wrong Bob/ Missed Bob Check in Gmail: Depending on which set of people you commonly email together, Gmail will warn you (or offer suggestions) to include the folks you may have missed. This will ensure you don't mistakingly leave out someone, or add someone you didn't want to email.
  3. Password Strength Indicators: When you sign up for an account on most websites, you are nowadays displayed a password strength indicator - which gives you feedback on the quality and strength of your chosen password. You may think that "Passw0rd" is an awesome password, but that's a mistake you are making! Websites have data collected over millions of users which can tell them things like what are common and easy to break passwords. They utilize this data, along with sophisticated software to create Password Strength indicators so that naive users don't mistakingly set simple, easy to guess passwords.
  4. Cmd-Q Warning In Chrome: Quite often Mac users make a mistake of pressing Cmd+Q to close a TAB instead of Cmd+W. Google Chrome on Mac can warn users when they press Cmd+Q, to help them from inadvertently closing all their windows.
  5. Spelling suggestions in Google suggest: Google will auto-suggest spelling corrections depending on what you might be searching. Helps users from making inadvertent mistakes.
  6. Undo Feature is nowadays present in most production quality successful software. Undo as a way of quickly "fixing" mistakes has become second-nature for most software users, that without this feature, most of us operate with a Save-paranoia. Gmail provided an Undo Send feature to provide a safety net for times when someone clicks Send by mistake.
  7. Double Entry Box: Most websites & software where one needs to enter a critical bank account number, or a password create option, users will notice that they are asked to enter the same value twice (with paste option disabled). This is to ensure people haven't made a mistake while entering the value, and that both boxes hold the same value.

Examples of Poke Yoke in Software Development

  1. Unit Tests + Pre-commit + CI + Build Radiators: Unit Tests are one of the strongest and most effective means of Mistake Proofing software development. They are precise and early in the development stage. They catch regression mistakes during refactoring, or bug fixing immediately. Unit Tests, coupled with a Continuous Integration Server (like Go, Jenkins, etc), a pre-commit script, and a Build Radiator are an excellent poka yoke mechanism to inform developers quickly about a mistake having occurred.
  2. IDEs and Compilers: IDE's indicate issues in code while you code. They will catch mistakes around incorrect type casting, generics, exception handling and provide you with possible fix options. Compilers will act as strict control mechanisms and will disallow any code that doesn't meet the syntax requirements (especially in case of Statically typed languages).
  3. Architectural Controls [ACs]: Some architectural poka yoke control examples in software:
    1. [AC] Hiding HttpSession: In some web projects folks would create a custom framework for development teams where a potential-to-misuse object like an HttpSession would be made unavailable. Instead, a custom "Session" object would be available which only has specific methods exposed like the getSessionID( ) method, so that application code could use the Session for its original purpose -- which was to identify the user's session, and not to act as a bag of data for passing around to pages and methods. It also ensures that there isn't much overhead in keeping session data synchronized across multiple machines in a cluster - since the ability of developers to stuff anything they like in the session object has been taken away. This will force the developers to look for data structures appropriate to their need for storing user specific application data.  
    2. [AC] Context aware injections: Custom frameworks can also be written to explicitly ensure that people don't perform an operation which is incorrect / invalid in the current application context. For instance, we would not like to perform updates during a GET Request (remember REST?). In such cases, the framework can inject appropriate implementations which do not support update method calls, so that a developer doesn't make a modifying call in the GET context.
    3. [AC] Running Under Least Privilege (RUPL): The paradigm of Running Under Least Privilege is popular at many levels in Software Development. Operating Systems now create processes which operate at Lowest Level of Privilege, so that processes cannot inadvertently wipe out a memory area which doesn't belong to them, or they do not mistakingly come under a virus attack and wipe out system secure space. Database connections at application level are given only read/update/delete row access on tables, rather than dba / admin access to ensure that the application cannot overwrite/drop tables by mistake. RUPL ensures that a process or a program is given only as much control as they need to avoid costly screw-ups.
    4. [AC] Circuit Breaker: Michael T. Nygard introduces this concept as a programming pattern in his masterpiece book ReleaseIt! The essential idea is similar to an electric current circuit breaker which trips open whenever the current load is high. The Circuit Breaker trips open whenever it detects that the call to an external web-service, database, etc took too long to respond, or timed-out. Once a circuit breaker is in Open State, it will immediately return an exception to any caller that attempts to connect to the external service. This has the advantage of protecting the external service from an overload of requests while it is attempting to recover, and also prevents the caller application threads from getting blocked. For more details read the concept and a sample Java AOP based implementation here. Circuit breaker acts as a poka yoke by preventing both the callee and the caller from unknowingly blowing up in case of a failure. 
    5. [AC] Types with Immutability: Passing a type (like a Money object), instead of passing primitives (like numbers) gives developers control over what can happen to the data as its passed along the various software layers, and what kind of operations can be performed on the data. Adding immutability to these types also ensures that an intermediate layer cannot inadvertently modify an internal data element while it is passing the type around.
  4. Password Log Check: To ensure that someone has not mistakingly logged sensitive user information like Credit Card Number, CVV or user password to a log file one can write a script to scan log files on the automation test machines. In automation tests, teams usually use only a small set of username/password/accounts/test-data, and hence checking for these accounts in log files, can help uncover if someone has mistakingly left a debug statement in code that prints sensitive data to the log. This would be a Warning Poka Yoke. A control poka yoke would be one where somehow the log API would disallow logging any variable/string which contained the words "credit card number" or "password" or "pwd", etc.
  5. Localization Test for Menu-Keyboard Shortcuts: Quite a few desktop softwares have menu options with Keyboard Shortcut keys (accelerators) which are shown underlined. The idea being that when someone presses "Alt+Character", then that menu option will get pressed. There are 2 requirements of these shortcut characters: First, the character must be present in the menu item, and Second, it must be unique in the menu. This is all fine when its designed, but quite often the keyboard shortcuts get messed up when they go through a localization process for other languages. Quite often translators will assign shortcuts which will clash with other menu options, since they don't fully understand which all menu options are shown together (especially in the case where menu changes dynamically based on roles). The solution in such cases is to write a poka yoke script that will check all menu options in a particular language to ensure there isn't a clash. This kind of bug detection is very cumbersome manually.
  6. Localization Message Bundle Checks: Localization in Java for instance is done through message bundlers (or properties file). Quite often translated files can have errors like translation of a specific line missed, or key misspelled, or key missing, etc. Such errors cannot be quickly caught through language testing. Instead a simple script that compares English Locale properties file against each Language property file can easily catch most of these errors through simple comparisons, and save precious heart aches later. These scripts can be run as part of the localization check-in to catch translation file errors immediately. Use of good translation tools can also eliminate these problems quite effectively, acting therefore as control poka yokes.
  7. Hiring the Right People: A very effective poka yoke to mistake proof your software. Something only few companies like ThoughtWorks get right :) 

Pragmatic Mistake Proofing

One needs to be pragmatic about mistake proofing to ensure it is effective, and doesn't irritate the hell out of its users. The guideline to deciding whether a Poka Yoke is needed is to look at feedback from the field. If an issue occurs quite frequently, and people seem to stumble upon it too often, then its most likely a candidate to apply a Poka Yoke. Also, if the blast radius of an issue going out in the field is very high, like logging passwords in clear text, then too, it makes sense to mistake proof the issue.


Conclusion

Poka Yoke techniques have been in software for sometime. The point to keep in mind, is to be aware of the fact that whenever there is something to warn to people -- instead of writing long emails, and bold font Wiki documents, one should pause and introspect. Ask the question: Can I re-design the system/ component/process such that mistakes cannot be made. Or, can I put in a check in software, such that if mistakes occur, then they can be caught quickly. If yes, then consider the Poka Yoke. 

Note: The idea of Poka Yoke in Software was presented by Dhaval Doshi and me in ThoughtWorks Bangalore xConf (July 2012) Slideshare Link. Based on positive reviews at the xConf we decided to write a blog on this topic since we could not find good enough resources on the Internet that spoke of Poka Yoke in Software. Thanks to fellow ThoughtWorkers Unmesh Joshi and Chirag Doshi for providing feedback and few suggestions on this topic.  

137 comments:

Gurpreet said...

Heroku's way of doing Poka Yoke. Check out this link:
http://www.heroku.com/how/deploy

hashimschmidt said...

one cannot use the special bolts in any place except the engine assembly, and one can also not inadvertently put the wrong (non-heat resistant) bolt in the engine assembly.i think its difficult to understand it but i will try it.

Gurpreet said...

The idea is that since the bolt size is unique, it won't fit any where else. Also for the same reason, some other bolt won't fit in the place where this special bolt is supposed to fit. So, that way -- we ensure that special bolt only fits in specific place :)

Anonymous said...

thanks for sharing..

Gurpreet said...

Another example of Poka Yoke in OpenMRS:

https://tickets.openmrs.org/browse/TRUNK-2517
"Write a unit test that checks for Deprecated methods in DWRServices"

Gurpreet said...

Test driven decoupling by owen rogers in agile india 2013 also ends up creating poka yokes where you write a unit test that enforces and checks if an invalid package dependency is being introduced in code.


http://betterconf.com/agileindia2013/index.html#session-94-info

Jason Yip said...

Poke yoke should really only refer to devices or designs that prevent particular mistakes. Fast detection is more jidoka.

Gurpreet said...

Jason, I am not sure I understand you fully. Wikipedia says the following: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Poka-yoke Shingo distinguished between the concepts of inevitable human mistakes and defects in the production. Defects occur when the mistakes are allowed to reach the customer. The aim of poka-yoke is to design the process so that mistakes can be detected and corrected immediately, eliminating defects at the source. And then it also says: Shingo argued that errors are inevitable in any manufacturing process, but that if appropriate poka-yokes are implemented, then mistakes can be caught quickly and prevented from resulting in defects. Can you elaborate more, hopefully with an example. Thanks.

Jason Yip said...

My impression is that poka yoke (aka mistake proofing) is about design of systems and methods to prevent mistakes whereas jidoka is the design of systems and methods where mistakes are detected to allow a human to correct them before leaking to the next stage.

For example, a continuous integration system is an example of jidoka. I might commit something that doesn't work but it will notify me of the mistake.

For poke yoke, the example that comes to mind is designing a language that prevents certain kinds of defects, see D.

Looking closer, it looks like Shingo considered those both types of "mistake proofing".

John Michle said...

Some facts and other points given here are quite considerable and to the point as well, would be better to look for more of these kind for efficient results.

Service Management Software

Anishi Ganatra said...

The target of developed is to create value-added goods in a timely way, which is free of charge of defect. Poke Yoke is useful in basic areas. The main purpose of Poka Yoke is to get zero defects. Since I am Embedded Product Engineering service provider at product development company based in India. Thanks for sharing useful post.

Softwares Cafe said...

Nice Post...you are all ways comming out with some grate stuff Softwarescafe

ankur rawat said...

we have new games developed by our developer check out the link http://technical-support-number.com/gmail-customer-services.html and tell us how you like the game?

Unknown said...

nice post Vendorzapp provides Mobile apps for small business, Ecommerce android apps development India, iOS ecommerce apps development, Ecommerce website Pune, Ready ecommerce website and apps. Android ecommerce apps then visit now Ecommerce android apps India, iOS ecommerce apps development, ecommerce website for small business call us +91-9850889625

sandeep gupta said...


Website & Software Development in Lucknow

Shreya Shukla said...

Nice post. Thanks for sharing and providing specific details. This is useful.

Website Development Company in Lucknow

Pals said...



Wow! That's really great information guys.I know lot of new things here. Really great contribution.Thank you ..



Custom Software Development India

Brn Infotech said...

Thank you for your post. This is excellent information. It is amazing and wonderful to visit your site.
iphone app training course

john stany said...

This article is very much helpful and i hope this will be an useful information for the needed one.Keep on updating these kinds of informative things...
iOS App Development Company
Android App Development Company

louis philip said...

Pretty article! I found some useful information in your blog, it was awesome to read, thanks for sharing this great content to my vision, keep sharing..
Sms marketing
Text message marketing
Fitness SMS

Inwizards Incorporation said...

Inwizards is an innovative creative website design and mobile app development Company with tons of experience in everything web & mobile app. We have been creating awesome and powerful responsive websites, and mobile app using xamarin platform that leverage businesses, organizations and startups to grow online quickly and organically.
iPhone Application Programmers India
Hire Angularjs Developer
hire dot net developer
Hire android app developer india

Designpluz said...

Web Design Sydney: I really appreciate this post and I like this very much. I am waiting for new post here and Please keep it up in future. .Logo Design Sydney,Logo Design in Coimbatore

Josoft Technologies Pvt. Ltd said...

Software Development in Lucknow India

Earmold Sydney said...


Lovely blog with much more interesting article, I will keep on reading your update. Thanks for the share Ear Plugs for Swimming Ear plugs for Sleeping Custom Ear Plugs

Shiva Infotech said...

This is the first time i read your blog and admire that you have posted on this...I really found useful.Keep updated.
Digital Signature Certificate provider
Online export documentation software
export documentation software
Online export documentation software
Photo catalog software

Prottoy Digital said...

Search Engine Optimization (SEO) Services. There are a variety of search engine optimizationservices which offer solutions for a ranking issues, and deficiencies. Depending on your goals, and needs one, or a combination, of the below services may be right for your website.

Tester said...

Custom iPhone Application Development in India

Sneha Jadhav said...

Thank you for sharing such great information.This blog was very helpful and informative, can you help me in finding out more detail on software development company ,i am interested and would like to know more about this field and wanted to understand the details about software consultancy 

Priti Singh said...

That is really nice post,
thaks for sharing this wonderful post.
keep it up.
Application Maintenance Services in India

Oyster Technology said...

Thanks for sharing this informative post..
Web Application Development Pune
Top Web Design & Development Company Pune
Digital Marketing Company Pune
E-commerce Development Pune

raju said...

Your website content is very effective and help full for people.I understood that you try to clear that concept about this subject.But i also read another content from another website. I think it's most better full content to your website content.So i suggest you, if you have a time to on your hand you will try to visit this website.Cracks software Download

ASO Services said...

Good post and I like it very much. By the way, anybody try this increase app downloads? I do not how to use.

Crack Taking said...


cracktaking is trusted source of all premium crack software, Serial Keys, Patches, Activators, Key gens, For all your devices Android, MAC, Windows. Cracktaking has a Great collection of all your Daily use Cracks Tools. https://cracktaking.com

crackstools said...

Your website content is very effective and help full for people.I understood that you try to clear that concept about this subject.http://crackstools.com

Ancy merina said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
helen shapiro said...

Best informative post that I have never seen. You are great with your this job.I am happy to see and follow your post every time. Thank you.
digital marketing services in delhi

sudipta kar said...

Interesting. Is it available? Btw please keep your laptop healthy .

Sojib Hasan said...

Algolia is the fastest and most relevant search experience available for Opencart. Algolia helps Opencart stores connect their users with what matters most via a search which delivers lightning-fast, relevant search results anywhere in the world.Purchasetheme is one kind of platform for the developers and designers. Whoever feels important can buy and sell the readymade work related to web development assets and print comprising scripts, codes, themes, banners, logos, graphics, plugins as well as mobile or desktop app source codes.What is semantic search? It's the technology that uses artificial intelligence (AI) to comprehend the user's intent behind every search query and also the context of the query.So, even if the user types in a query with minor typos or spelling errors, it tries to get into the mind of the user to understand what he was probably thinking and what results he seeks. Opencart Search Extension

Ansar Ali said...

Thanks for the information your article brings. I see the novelty of your writing, I will share it for everyone to read together. I look forward to reading many articles from you.
customer service
amazon stock
bitcoin price

iMedia Solutions said...

Thank you for posting the quality & unique content for us, I respect your time and efforts.


https://imediasolutions.in/india/logo-designer-online.php

Rahul Malhotra said...

Hi, I am Rahul thank you for this informative post.Thank you so much and for you all the best. (fmovies.in.net) That is a great job. Wish you more success. Takes Down
fmovies

Developer Brothers said...

Thank You for sharing the blog. It is really nice.

best Website Design Development and Mobile Application Development company in Kanpur India Australia USA
Best Android and iOS Mobile Application Development in Kanpur India Australia USA

Nutra Trials said...

Nutra Trials defines personal characteristics of different health products including skincare, weight loss, muscle and male enhancement. The study presented here is briefly described for reader convenience and to deliver them assurance with health standards. The best possible answers are given here regarding the selection of an ideal supplement or cream or serum that possibly remains to be safe for health and do not cause any side effects.

Unknown said...

Thanks for Sharing this Excellent Information. I like very much.
best hospital management software services in hyderabad

NutraT line said...

It is a great job, I like your posts and wish you all the best. and I hope you continue this job well.
NutraT line

piinn said...

I think this article will fully complement you. Please continue publishing helpful topics like this. Regards, from Asset Management Software

Asset Tracking Software

Property Maintenance Software


ABSPL said...

Thank you for your post. This is excellent information.

Data entry projects
data entry work
data entry services
data entry process

thomus jons said...

Hello, I am thomus jons thank you for this informative post. That is a great job. Wish you more success.Thank you so much and for you all the best. Takes Down
123movies

Steve Coleman said...

TecSmash is your ultimate source of Technology news and Make Money Online product reviews. We research and review all Tech, MMO, Biz Opp and IM products.
Tecsmash

john nickson said...

I think you have shared a great content ..looks great and I got to know many things.. kindly click on the links below if you are looking for any of the services mentioned below:-\
Software development company in lucknow
IT outsourcing company in Lucknow
Finance software company in Lucknow
Finance software company in Lucknow
Banking software development in Lucknow
Website development company in Lucknow
Ecommerce development in Lucknow

PromoSys Technology said...

I read your blog and admire that you have posted on this...I really found useful.Keep updated.
AutoCAD Training in Lucknow
Winter Training in Lucknow
REVIT Training in Lucknow
PHP Training in Lucknow
Python Training in Lucknow
HVAC training in Lucknow

Steve Coleman said...

Income designers.com is the number one destination to find genuine make money online programs and services incomedesigners

Tania Inna said...

HealRun is a health news blog we provide the latest news about health, Drugs and latest Diseases and conditions. We update our users with health tips and health products reviews. If you want to know any information about health or health product (Side Effects & Benefits) Feel Free To ask HealRun Support Team.

Steve Coleman said...

Here is our FB SociCake Review, in which I have revealed the good, bad and ugly about Mario Browns FB SociCake Facebook Marketing Tool. fb socicake review

Supplements For Fitness said...

Supplements For Fitness male characters cope with their apparent disappearance of their masculinity. However, the reality of sexual failure is not so funny. In real life, the girl returns home empty-handed, and the boy waits for him to spend several .

Testo Ram UK said...

Pilpedia is supplying 100 percent original and accurate information at each moment of time around our site and merchandise, and the intent is to improve the usage of good and pure health supplement. For More Info please visit Pilpedia online store.

Supplements Book said...

Vital Keto : Je sais que c'est plus facile à dire qu'à faire, mais essayez-moi. Il est fantastique de savoir comment les grosses perruques ne peuvent pas suivre une simple transaction comme celle-ci.

Visitez-nous : Vital Keto

Vous pouvez également visiter : bit.ly/2QNfWny

Beauty Secret Answers said...


Renewal Derm: You'll be able to't go into Skin care blindly. This was historic. I, officially, must not soak up Skin care. One of these items is Skin care. This can be just what I need. As expected, I will be stubborn. That's an ideal time for obtaining a Skin care. I haven't really got anything to feature in reference to Skin care.

https://beautysecretanswers.com/renewal-derm-skin/

nutrifitweb said...

Genodrive : Of course, several of them will be rather dangerous. I'm always reserved. What precisely is Male Health? It will prevent scratch, but only if you know what you are doing. It's what Male Enhancement has done on behalf of me. There's a guarantee that you may get Male Enhancement because at least you've got choices. Testosterone booster is your goal. Male Enhancement provides the paramount data one desires for Male Enhancement.

BUY NOW HERE : https://www.nutrifitweb.com/genodrive/

Read More : https://www.smore.com/q9b6t-viralis-rx

Suruchi Pandey said...

Highly informative and considerable write-up published by you. I admire you for making this tremendous work accessible here. Keep posting and continue updating. Professional Web design services are provided by W3BMINDS- Website designer in Lucknow.
Web development Company | Web design company

Gfe Bangalore said...

High profile Bangalore Escorts 
High profile Bangalore Escorts 
High profile Bangalore Escorts 
Celebrity Bangalore Escorts 
Celebrity Bangalore Escorts 
Celebrity Bangalore Escorts 
Celebrity Bangalore Escorts 
High Profile escorts in bangalore 

Chiến SEOCAM said...

Miskien is dit in goed artikel dat ik ea lêze. Tankewol foar dielen


máy massage chân

chậu ngâm chân

máy matxa chân

máy ngâm chân

Chiến SEOCAM said...

ஒருவேளை இது நான் பார்த்த ஒரு நல்ல கட்டுரை. பகிர்வதற்கு நன்றி


lưới chống chuột

cửa lưới dạng xếp

cửa lưới tự cuốn

cửa lưới chống muỗi

learn Coading said...

Great Post Thanks for Shearing. i Read your Blog every day.Please write more about this topics.it very bothersome to tell the reality then again I’ll definitely come back again.Please write more about this topics.
More

Wilma Gomez said...

The Probiotic supplement helps to balance good bacteria and in this regard, Probiotic t-50 review is creating buzz. How far is the supplement reliable and worth considering, you will come to know about it here.

Wilma Gomez said...

The Probiotic supplement helps to balance good bacteria and in this regard, Probiotic t-50 review is creating buzz. How far is the supplement reliable and worth considering, you will come to know about it here.

Chiến SEOCAM said...

Жадаю вам быў працэс ці артыкулы. Спадзяюся, у наступны раз, калі вы будзеце мець лепшую артыкул

chó Corgi

bán chó Corgi

chó Corgi giá bao nhiêu

mua chó Corgi

john said...

Nice blog. Thanks for sharing such great information
IT consulting services
Forex trading software
Bespoke software development company in London
Money Transfer Software company

I am following your blog regularly and got great information. Thanks for an insightful post.These tips are really helpful.

Adam said...

Nice post, very useful blogs with very useful information, thank you for sharing this post software product development companies in india

Adam said...

Nice post, very useful blogs with very useful information, thank you for sharing this post software product development companies in india

Designer said...

Bazı kadınlar erkeklerini ( bé 5 tuổi  học toán )takip etmeyi, bazıları da hayallerini( cách dạy toán tư duy cho trẻ ) takip etmeyi seçiyor. Hala bir seçeneğiniz( dạy trẻ học toán tư duy ) varsa, bir kariyerin uyanıp sizi artık sevmediğinizi( toán mầm non ) söyleyen bir gün asla olmayacağını unutmayın.

Dale Morris said...

Norton antivirus phone number
McAfee antivirus phone number
Malwarebytes customer support number
Hp printer support contact number
Canon printer support online

Career Infra-Best Real Estate Company said...

Nice blog..! I really loved reading through this article.Thanks for sharing.
Please do visit my website hope you'll like it:
Best real estate company in Lucknow
Best properties in Lucknow
Best plots in Lucknow
Fastest growing real estate company in Lucknow
Best Real estate company
Best development company in Lucknow

Allied Health School said...

Nice blog..!Thanks for sharing.
Please do visit my website hope you'll like it: Best Allied health school in Lucknow
Best allied health school
Paramedical institute in Lucknow
Best health school in Lucknow

Prayas Infra-Best Real Estate Consultant said...

Prayas:-
Thanks for sharing blog this post is wonderful....your posts are just awesome.
Please do visit my website hope you'll like it: Best real estate properties in Lucknow
Best real estate company in Lucknow
Best property dealer
Best properties in Lucknow

Meal4u said...

Meal:-
I have read many of your post and this post is wonderful.... all of your post are just awesome
Please do visit my website hope you'll like it: Best Restraunt in Lucknow
Best Tiffin service in Lucknow
Best Tiffin Service
Best Homemade Food

Adarsh Bagwani Paudhsala said...

Adarsh:-
Nice blog..! Thanks for posting useful information.You have provided an nice article,
Please do visit my website hope you'll like it: Best nursery plants in Jaunpur
Best nursery services
Best Nursery plants
Best Bagwani services

VINAY SINGH said...


Thanks for sharing the knowledgeable stuff to enlighten us no words for this amazing blog.. learnt so many things I recommend everyone to learn something from this blogger and blog.. I am sharing it with others also..
We are a professional training institute providing training under the following courses, if any one is looking for them click on the blink below:
Summer training in Lucknow
SAP training in Lucknow
SAP FICO training in Lucknow
Python Training in Lucknow
Advance Java Training in Lucknow
SEO Training in Lucknow
Digital marketing training in Lucknow
PHP Training in Lucknow
Android Training in Lucknow

Agnes said...

h3ncash adalah agen Sbobet Mobile menjadi situs taruhan bola online ter besar yang memiliki banyak pemain di dalam nya dan telah menikmati fasilitas yang ada. Selain itu sbobet mobile juga menyedia kan permainan lain Casino, Slot, atau poker.

Jenniper said...

pokerblibli adalah salah satu poker online yang paling diminati saat ini, selain banyak bonus yang bisa di dapat. ayo tunggu apalagi, bergabunglah dengan poker online blibli

Jennifer said...

Agen Sbobet h3ncash Situs judi yang mempunyai banyak pemain dan situs judi online terbesar diindonesia. dengan pelayanan dan keramahan agen yang berkualitas.

Juliesar said...

h3ncash adalah situs yang akan memberikan anda sebuah permainan Judi Sbobet yang terbaik dan terpercaya tentunya. Sesuai dengan visi misi yang selalu mengembangkan internal kami. Untuk meningkatkan inovasi dalam memberikan yang terbaik di antara yang terbaik bagi para petaruh judi di Indonesia.

Unknown said...

Thanks for sharing this information. I really Like Very Much.
online training institute

Unknown said...

We the branding experts, illustration, UI/UX service provider. As images of products are the biggest weapon for a business company. Perfect Art service means a lot to this professional business purpose. Do Visit to have more knowledge about unique service.

Adarsh Bagwani Paudhsala said...

Nice blog..! Thanks for posting useful information.You have provided an nice article,
Please do visit my website hope you'll like it: Best nursery plants in Jaunpur
Best nursery services
Best Nursery plants
Best Bagwani services

Meal4u said...

I have read many of your post and this post is wonderful.... all of your post are just awesome
Please do visit my website hope you'll like it: Best tiffin service provider in Lucknow
Best Tiffin service in Lucknow
Best Tiffin Service
Best Homemade Food

Prayas Infra-Best Real Estate Consultant said...

Thanks for sharing blog this post is wonderful....your posts are just awesome.
Please do visit my website hope you'll like it: Best real estate properties in Lucknow
Best real estate company in Lucknow
Best property dealer
Best properties in Lucknow

Career Infra-Best Real Estate Company said...

Nice blog..! I really loved reading through this article.Thanks for sharing.
Please do visit my website hope you'll like it:
Best real estate company in Lucknow
Best properties in Lucknow
Best plots in Lucknow
Fastest growing real estate company in Lucknow
Best Real estate company
Best development company in Lucknow

Allied Health School said...

Nice blog..!Thanks for sharing.
Please do visit my website hope you'll like it: Best Allied health school in Lucknow
Best allied health school
Paramedical institute in Lucknow
Best health school in Lucknow

SR Group- Best Real Estate Company said...

Nice blog..! Really very informative and creative contents. This concept is a good way to enhance the knowledge. Please do visit my website hope you'll like it:
Best real estate company in Lucknow
Best properties in Lucknow
Best plots in Lucknow
Top real estate company in Lucknow
Best Real estate company
Best development company in Lucknow

aa said...

PekanQQ merupakan Situs Poker Online yang menyediakan berbagai permainan seperti Poker, Ceme, Ceme Keliling, CAPSA, Super10, Omaha Dan domino qiu qiu. Mudah Menang, Mudah Jadi Jutawan.

aa said...

Pekanpoker merupakan Agen Poker Online yang menyediakan berbagai permainan seperti Poker, Ceme, Ceme Keliling, CAPSA, Super10, Omaha Dan domino Qiu Qiu. Selain permainan yang lengkap, Pekanpoker juga menyediakan Customer Servis yang ramah. Raih kemenangan besar bersama Pekanqq.com

Meal4u said...

I have read many of your post and this post is wonderful.... all of your post are just awesome
Please do visit my website hope you'll like it: Best tiffin service provider in Lucknow
Best Tiffin service in Lucknow
Best Tiffin Service
Best Homemade Food

Career Infra-Best Real Estate Company said...

Nice blog..! I really loved reading through this article.Thanks for sharing.
Please do visit my website hope you'll like it:
Best real estate company in Lucknow
Best properties in Lucknow
Best plots in Lucknow
Fastest growing real estate company in Lucknow
Best Real estate company
Best development company in Lucknow

Prayas Infra-Best Real Estate Consultant said...

Thanks for sharing blog this post is wonderful....your posts are just awesome.
Please do visit my website hope you'll like it: Best real estate properties in Lucknow
Best real estate company in Lucknow
Best property dealer
Best properties in Lucknow

Adarsh Bagwani Paudhsala said...

Nice blog..! Thanks for posting useful information.You have provided an nice article,
Please do visit my website hope you'll like it: Best nursery plants in Jaunpur
Best nursery services
Best Nursery plants
Best Bagwani services

Allied Health School said...

Nice blog..!Thanks for sharing.
Please do visit my website hope you'll like it: Best Allied health school in Lucknow
Best allied health school
Paramedical institute in Lucknow
Best health school in Lucknow

SR Group- Best Real Estate Company said...

Nice blog..! Really very informative and creative contents. This concept is a good way to enhance the knowledge. Please do visit my website hope you'll like it:
Best real estate company in Lucknow
Best properties in Lucknow
Best plots in Lucknow
Top real estate company in Lucknow
Best Real estate company
Best development company in Lucknow

Elasa Roy said...

I appreciate you and I would like to read your post. Is very Useful artical . Thanks for sharing this useful information.Your site is very demand able.

Akhand Pratap Singh said...

I have read many of your posts and this post is wonderful.... all of your posts is just awesome.
Please do visit my website hope you'll like it.Brst Real Estate Company In Lucknow
Bigtown Group

healthygnc said...

Healthy GNC - In usa is a wide variety of health,wellness and Male health performance products.which has include protein,male health performance and weight Loss management supplements.This product is really made to help improve your health, whether you are at the beginning of your fitness. Healthy GNC,gnc,weightloss,bodybuilding,vitamins,energy,fitness,strength,healthfulness,stamin,Wellness.
For more info - http://www.healthygnc.com/

Akhand Pratap Singh said...

Bigtown group is the best real estate comapny in lucknow
we provide luxirious homes and apartments in lucknow
for more info visit us: Bigtown Group

Akhand Pratap Singh said...

Lucknow developers and Colonizer is the best real estate development comapny in lucknow
Buy Best Property and plots in Lucknow from the best real estate company in lucknow
We provide luxirious Homes and apartments in lucknow. we also provide best plots to our clients at very affordable price
For more info visit us: Lucknow Developer

Akhand Pratap Singh said...

Lucknow developers and colonizer is a Best Real Estate development company in Lucknow for property and plots.
Buy Best Property and plots in Lucknow from the best real estate company in lucknow.
Hurry-up and contact us for plots and properties in Lucknow and near by locations.
Best Real Estate Company in Lucknow,Best Real Estate Development Company In Lucknow, Residential Plots In Lucknow,Commercial plots in lucknow best properties in lucknow, cheap plots in lucknow,Lucknow Developers, lucknow developers and colonizer,homes for sale in lucknow,homes for sale by owner in lucknow,commercial real estate,commercial real estate in lucknow,lucknow real estate, houses for sale near me ,plots for sale near me.

For more info visit us: Lucknow Developer

john said...

Thanks for sharing the knowledgeable stuff to enlighten us no words for this amazing blog.I have bookmarked it on my pc. If you are looking for any of the services mentioned below, click on the hyperlinks
IT consulting services
Money transfer system
Money Transfer Software company
Online Money remittance platform
Software development in London
Software development company in London

You can also visit: www.generalsoftwares.com

Weight Loss Diet said...

Keto Slim Diet is a dietary enhancement that is known for quick fat consuming and can help in improving the nature of wellbeing. This fat consuming item is planned with characteristic fixings. http://www.choosetolose.net/keto-slim-diet-weight-loss-pills-reviews/

Lubna Usmani said...


Hey Very Nice Blog!! Thanks For Sharing !!!

SEO in Varanasi
Best Website Developement Company in Varanasi
Website Designing in Varanasi

Weight Loss Tips said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Weight Loss Tips said...

Green Coffee Beans Extract is one of them.... it is currently among the world's most popular weight loss supplements. As the name implies, this supplement is extracted from Green Coffee Beans. It contains a substance called Chlorogenic Acid, which is believed to be responsible for the weight loss effects.

Ashish Singh said...

NICE Blog!
Website Development Company in Lucknow 

Photo Retouching Services said...

Photo Retouching is one of the most impressive services in photo editing. It helps to bring a positive vibe and look on the photos. Most of the end-level users are in great needs of Photo Retouching Services. But you need to be careful while selecting the best one.
Chat conversation end
Type a message...

Health Care Products said...

Getting your fat gets down is the best gift that you can give to your body. This Supplement is known as the Pure Natural Keto. Weight loss can give stress, and sometimes it becomes so difficult to lose weight that you all feel depressed. But making yourself more stressed out is not the option for weight loss. Weight loss can be very easy with this amazing formula, and this is called Pure Natural Keto. Kindly Visit on Pure Natural Keto Fat Burner

Photo Background Editor said...


Photo Background Editor plays a key role in removing the background of the photo. The editor needs to remain highly careful while removing the background. The service is an essential one for the online business community.

Weight Loss Tips said...

Keto Blast is a natural weight loss supplement designed by a well-known keto brand. Its other product is working, but this one is unique in its formulation and working. The product is 100% pure and valid option for weight loss because not directly address the weight loss and body shape up. The best thing about this product is that it cannot give you any harm and quickly put you in ketosis. This is a natural slimming product that is having natural ingredients. It is the advanced formula for weight loss that is going amazing in its working when it comes to weight management. Visit On http://www.healthenrich.org/keto-blast-keto-diet-pills-weight-loss-supplement/

Health Related Products said...

Keto Blast is a nutritional supplement that promises an extraordinary weight-loss, optimal BHB solution, and greatly enhanced way of living within just thirty days.
It has certainly become an incredibly in demand fat loss tool that may in a natural way kick individuals right into an instant weight loss mode. Right now, as all keto dieters understand, getting into ketosis as well as staying there could be a good deal of effort and willpower. Kindly Visit On Keto Blast Weight Loss Pills

Proven Ways to Grow your Instagram said...

Benefits of hiring a Karachi Call Girl, Now let’s talk about the benefits of using this Karachi call Girls. Firstly, you gеt to try out аll different tуреѕ of lаdiеѕ. Yоu mау find оnе particular tуре (bоdу-tуре оr ѕеrviсе) tо bе еxсеllеnt, a tуре уоu hаd not еvеn соnѕidеrеd bеfоrе. Pеrhарѕ уоu like girlѕ from […]
https://www.escortgirlsinpakistan.pk

Health And Skincare Products said...

Nitro Strength is a muscle booster supplement that works awesomely for all men adults. It enhances the virility and vitality, sexual desires and endurance level and gives a better sexual performance like a beast. Regular intake of supplement rectifies the erectile dysfunction by giving enlarged erections which is even harder and thicker that will definitely satisfy your partner. It boosts nitric oxide in blood tissues of the penis and does the miracle of swiping out the erectile dysfunction issue. The supplement also increases the testosterone level in the body that is responsible for male reproductive organs and functions and maintains the wellness of sex. Along with enhances sexual vitality, virility, and sexual stamina so you can experience better sexual performance. Visit On http://www.theapexme.com/nitro-strength-muscle-builder-performance-enhancer/

Ashish Singh said...

Very nice and inspiring post. Thanks for sharing. SEO Company in Lucknow

MindtechAffiliates said...

thank you for sharing this useful information

Thanks
Cpa offers

Suruchi Pandey said...

We are leading responsive website designing and development company in Lucknow. We are offering mobile friendly responsive website designing, website development, e-commerce website, seo service and sem services in Lucknow. Professional Web design services are provided by W3BMINDS- Website designer in Lucknow.
Web development Company | Web design company

arahwnally said...

I read this Blog very nice...
https://www.drozus.com

arahwnallya said...

Thanks for sharing this useful information! I am very happy to read this article
https://www.drozus.com

Meritstep Technologies said...

Thanks for sharing this information. I really Like Very Much.
blockchain online training

shriya sharma said...

Thanks for sharing that post with us.               
https://www.drozus.com

oxienally said...

Your information is really helpful for me.               
https://www.drozus.com

oxienally said...

Your information is really helpful for me.               
https://www.drozus.com

monika jena said...

TimesForEducation.com - Everyday News Portal Of Education

TimesForEducation
https://timesforeducation.com/

TimesForEducation. We Regularly Update Education's News From All Over The Worlds. Our Mission Not Only Provide Education's News But Also People Get Become Educated. Visit also this website: https://timesforeducation.com/

===========================================================

normal comment. TimesForEducation. We Regularly Update Education's News From All Over The Worlds. Our Mission Not Only Provide Education's News But Also People Get Become Educated. Visit also this website: https://timesforeducation.com/

normal comment. TimesForEducation. We Regularly Update Education's News From All Over The Worlds. Our Mission Not Only Provide Education's News But Also People Get Become Educated. Visit also this website: https://timesforeducation.com/


THE EXPERTIZE said...

thanks for wonderful information..
Data analytics training in Lucknow

MIS Training in Lucknow

HR Training in Lucknow

Graphic designing training in Lucknow

Advanced Excel Training in Lucknow

Digital Marketing Training in Lucknow

Auctech IT Solution said...

Thanks for sharing this useful information!
I am very happy to read this article
Thanks Again For Sharing......
Website Development Service In Lucknow
E-Commerce Website In Lucknow
Logo Designer In Lucknow
3D Company in Lucknow
Graphic Design In Lucknow
3D graphics company in lucknow
Motion Graphic Company in Lucknow
Brochure Design Company In Lucknow
3D Walkthrough Company



Digital Marketing Company in Vijayawada said...

Useful Information :

Looking for the Best Digital Marketing Company in Vijayawada and Hyderabad affiliate agency in south INDIA, Digital Marketing in Vijayawada @ praiseads.com

kritika webpace said...

Thanks for sharing this great information, your blogs is so informative and knowledgable.
We are best Seo services company in delhi
Mobile app development company in Delhi

Walkin Interview For Freshers said...

Great Article:

Looking for the Best Walkin Interview For Freshers , Find latest Govt Job Notifications with various information such as govt vacancies, eligibility, Bank Jobs, Latest Bank Job Updates @ pdtvjobs.com

Sensigo Technologies said...

Software Development Company We specialize in Blockchain development, Artificial Intelligence, DevOps, Mobile App development, Web App development and all your customised online solutions. Get best impression at online by our services, we are familiar for cost effectiveness, quality, delivery and support.

Walkin Interview For Freshers said...

Great Article

Looking for the Best Walkin Interviews For Freshers , Find latest Govt Job Notifications with various information such as govt vacancies, eligibility, Bank Jobs, Latest Bank Job Updates @ pdtvjobs.com

Digital Marketing Company in Vijayawada said...

Useful Information :

Looking for the Best Digital Marketing Company in Vijayawada and Hyderabad affiliate agency in south INDIA, Digital Marketing in Vijayawada @ praiseads.com

nnownnally said...

Your style is very unique compared to other people I've read stuff from. Many thanks for posting when you've got the opportunity, Guess I will just bookmark this blog               
https://www.drozus.com

nnownnally said...

https://techtipsfromateacher.blogspot.com/2014/01/using-ipod-nano-5g-with-linux.html?showComment=1535522753968#c850040276255530161